@dibyendu Not sure what the issue is, but I am trying to bring some relevant information to the surface. Maybe the issue becomes apparent to someone else.
This is how your preCICE configuration currently looks like, visualized:
Acceleration configuration:
<max-iterations value="40" />
<relative-convergence-measure limit="1.0e-5" data="Temperature" mesh="Fluid-lowerSolid-Mesh" />
<relative-convergence-measure limit="1.0e-5" data="Heat-Flux" mesh="lowerSolid-Mesh" />
<relative-convergence-measure data="Heat-Flux" mesh="Fluid-upperSolid-Mesh" limit="1e-5" />
<relative-convergence-measure
data="Temperature"
mesh="upperSolid-Mesh"
limit="1e-5" />
<acceleration:IQN-ILS>
<data mesh="Fluid-lowerSolid-Mesh" name="Temperature" />
<data mesh="lowerSolid-Mesh" name="Heat-Flux" />
<data name="Temperature" mesh="upperSolid-Mesh" />
<data name="Heat-Flux" mesh="Fluid-upperSolid-Mesh" />
<initial-relaxation value="0.01" />
<max-used-iterations value="50" />
<time-windows-reused value="8" />
<filter type="QR2" limit="1e-3" />
</acceleration:IQN-ILS>
Looking at the fluid-openfoam/precice-Fluid-iterations.log
:
TimeWindow TotalIterations Iterations Convergence QNColumns DeletedQNColumns DroppedQNColumns
1 11 11 1 10 0 0
2 42 31 1 20 20 0
3 43 1 1 20 20 0
4 44 1 1 20 20 0
5 45 1 1 20 20 0
6 46 1 1 20 20 0
...
5194 5234 1 1 20 20 0
5195 5235 1 1 20 20 0
I think it is suspicious that after the second time window, it always takes one iteration. It also seems like every time window is converging.
Looking at the convergence log:
TimeWindow Iteration ResRel(Temperature) ResRel(Heat-Flux) ResRel(Heat-Flux) ResRel(Temperature)
1 1 inf 1.00000000e+00 inf inf
1 2 1.00000000e+00 9.90000000e-01 1.00000000e+00 inf
1 3 4.65484637e-01 6.39474296e-02 4.65484637e-01 1.00000000e+00
1 4 8.36829374e-02 6.16634129e-05 5.91097005e-02 6.54257136e-04
1 5 6.94841058e-02 1.71483305e-03 4.90230842e-02 4.82989472e-03
1 6 2.62703431e-03 8.67889403e-05 4.08458512e-03 2.01203375e-04
1 7 7.88433309e-05 9.14203344e-04 1.31189746e-04 1.91521046e-04
1 8 1.84460302e-04 1.60743230e-05 2.59511491e-04 8.70440890e-06
1 9 2.26766342e-05 5.85727836e-05 2.69340868e-05 1.24876849e-05
1 10 1.16792474e-05 7.12866156e-07 1.39805558e-05 1.34874121e-07
@dibyendu @uekerman Do you see something I don’t see?
My gut feeling tells me something is wrong with the acceleration (which data is accelerated on which mesh) or the convergence measures.
By the way, I am still a bit confused: you define upperSolid
-Fluid
-lowerSolid
, but at the same time you write above:
You could also look into the partitioned heat conduction tutorials: Partitioned heat conduction | preCICE - The Coupling Library
By the way (again): is this case related to Configuring a Solid-Solid-Fluid CHT case in OpenFOAM?